Australia version. Australian dollars, stamp duty in the up-front costs (Victorian rates in the examples), council rates and strata levies, rent converted from weekly, and no deduction for interest on your own home. US version
Rent or Buy Calculator (Australia)
Rent or buy in Australia? Compare net worth in dollars with stamp duty, first home buyer exemptions, council rates, strata levies and weekly rent turned monthly.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Rent vs Buy Calculator?
Rent in Australia is quoted by the week, so convert it first: $600 a week is $2,600 a month (600 x 52 / 12). Against that, an $800,000 established house in Melbourne with a 20% deposit and a 6% loan over 30 years costs $3,837.12 a month in repayments, before council rates, insurance and upkeep. At 4% price growth and a 6% return on the renter's savings, the renter is still about $11,300 ahead after 10 years.
Stamp duty is most of that gap. In Victoria, general land transfer duty on a dutiable value between $130,000 and $960,000 is $2,870 plus 6% of the amount over $130,000, so an $800,000 purchase pays $43,070. The tool counts it, with conveyancing and transfer fees, as money spent on day one that the renter keeps invested instead.
First home buyers change the picture. Victoria exempts first home buyers from duty on a dutiable value up to $600,000 and gives a concession up to $750,000; other states have their own thresholds. A $600,000 unit with strata levies of $4,000 a year, against $520 a week in rent, moves ahead of renting in year 3 and leads by about $76,700 after 10 years at the same growth assumptions.
- Net worth comparison with opportunity cost of the down payment and closing costs
- Selling costs, maintenance, property tax, insurance and HOA
- Mortgage interest and property tax deduction at your marginal rate
- Break-even year, cumulative cost and net worth charts
- Shareable link with every input
Updated
How to use the Rent vs Buy Calculator
- Convert the weekly rent to monthly (weekly x 52 / 12) and enter it, with a yearly rent increase you think the market will bear.
- Enter the price, your deposit, the loan rate and term. Repayments are worked monthly; fortnightly repayments of half the monthly amount pay a loan off a little faster.
- In Stamp Duty and Purchase Costs, add your state's transfer duty from its revenue office calculator, plus conveyancing, mortgage registration and any lenders mortgage insurance if your deposit is under 20%.
- Enter council rates, building insurance, maintenance and strata levies for the owner and contents insurance for the renter. Leave the tax rate at 0.
- Set selling costs to the agent commission and marketing you expect and compare the break-even year with how long you plan to stay.
Worked examples
Established Melbourne house, not a first home
Input
$800,000, $160,000 deposit, 6% over 30 years, $45,570 up-front ($43,070 Victorian duty, $2,500 conveyancing and fees), council rates $2,200, insurance $1,800, maintenance $4,000, 2.5% selling costs, rent $600 a week ($2,600 a month) rising 3%, 4% growth, 6% return, 10 years
Output
Repayments $3,837.12 a month; renting ahead by $62,067 after year 1 and by $11,252 after 10 years
The buyer gains on the renter by between $3,900 and $7,700 each year, so the break-even falls just after year 10. Stay longer or buy below this price-to-rent ratio and buying wins.
First home buyer, $600,000 unit
Input
$600,000, $120,000 deposit, no duty under the Victorian first home buyer exemption, $2,500 fees, strata levies $4,000, council rates $1,500, insurance $400, maintenance $2,000, rent $520 a week rising 3%
Output
Repayments $2,877.84 a month; buying ahead from year 3 and by $76,713 after 10 years
Without $40,000-plus of duty to recover, the buyer overtakes quickly. Check eligibility before relying on it: the exemption needs a dutiable value of $600,000 or less, and the concession ends at $750,000.
Background and insight
The fair comparison is net worth, not monthly payments. The approach follows the structure popularised by the New York Times rent-versus-buy calculator: the renter starts with the down payment and closing costs invested, and every year whichever household spends less invests the difference at the investment return. The buyer ends with the home's value after selling costs, minus the remaining loan, plus anything they invested. Leaving out that opportunity cost makes buying look better than it is.
With the defaults (400,000 home, 80,000 down, 8,000 closing, 6.5% for 30 years, 2,500 rent), the monthly principal and interest is 2,022.62. In year one the buyer is 22,128 behind, mostly because 6% selling costs and 8,000 of closing costs vanish on day one. The buyer moves ahead in year 3 and leads by about 113,700 after 10 years at 3% appreciation and 7% investment return. Set selling costs to 0 and buying wins from year 1, which shows how much transaction costs matter if you might move soon.
The tax line assumes you itemise and can deduct all mortgage interest and property tax. In the US many households take the standard deduction instead, and state and local tax deductions are capped, so for them the real benefit is smaller or zero. Set Marginal Tax Rate to 0 to see the result without it.
Common use cases
Deciding whether to buy now
Find the break-even year and compare it with how long you expect to stay.
Testing a rate change
Change the Interest Rate to see how much a point on the mortgage moves the payment and the outcome.
Comparing a specific listing and rental
Enter real tax, HOA and rent figures for two homes you are choosing between.
Checking an agent's claim
Test "rent is dead money" by adding the opportunity cost of the down payment.
Tips and limitations
- With less than a 20% deposit most lenders charge lenders mortgage insurance; add its quote to the up-front costs or the loan.
- An offset account reduces interest like extra repayments; the tool does not model one, so treat its result as without offset.
- Council rates are an owner cost (a landlord pays them, not the tenant), so enter them only on the buying side.
- Super is not touched here: the renter's return is on money outside super, such as an ETF portfolio.
- Stamp duty rules and concessions differ in NSW, Queensland and the other states, so use your state revenue office figure.
Sources and further reading
- General land transfer duty property current rates, State Revenue Office Victoria
- First home buyer duty exemption, concession or reduction, State Revenue Office Victoria. Exemption to $600,000 and concession to $750,000.
- Your main residence (home), Australian Taxation Office. Main residence exemption from capital gains tax.
Frequently asked questions
How much stamp duty is there on an $800,000 house in Victoria?
At the general rates for contracts from 1 July 2021, $2,870 plus 6% of the value above $130,000, which is $43,070. Off-the-plan, principal place of residence and pensioner concessions can lower it, so check the State Revenue Office calculator for your case.
Do first home buyers pay stamp duty in Victoria?
Not on a dutiable value of $600,000 or less, and a sliding concession applies above that up to $750,000. You lose eligibility if you or your partner have already had a First Home Owner Grant or a first home buyer duty exemption or concession.
Can I claim interest on the home I live in?
No. Interest is deductible only when the loan earns assessable income, such as on a rental property, which is where negative gearing comes in. For a home you live in the deduction is nil, so this version sets the tax rate to 0.
Will I pay capital gains tax when I sell my home?
Usually not. Your main residence is exempt if you are an Australian resident, it was your home for the whole time you owned it, it was not used to produce income and the land is 2 hectares or less. Renting it out can reduce the exemption.
Should I enter weekly rent?
Enter monthly rent: multiply the weekly figure by 52 and divide by 12. Multiplying by 4 understates a year of rent by about 8%, because a year has 52 weeks, not 48.
Where do strata levies go?
In Strata Levies. They cover building insurance, common areas and the sinking fund, so an apartment owner's own building insurance and maintenance are usually lower than for a house. A tenant does not pay them directly.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Rent vs Buy Calculator?
Yes. “Rent vs Buy: Comparing Net Worth, Not Monthly Payments” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.