Canada version. Canadian dollars, fixed rates compounded semi-annually, land transfer tax and CMHC premiums in the up-front costs, condo fees, and no deduction for interest on the home you live in. US version

Rent or Buy Calculator (Canada)

Rent or buy in Canada? Compare net worth with land transfer tax, CMHC insurance, condo fees and a fixed rate compounded semi-annually, as Canadian mortgages are.

The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.

About this tool

What is the Rent vs Buy Calculator?

A Toronto condo at $850,000 with 20% down and a 4.5% five-year fixed rate over a 25-year amortization costs $3,763.62 a month. That is not the figure a US calculator gives: Canadian fixed-rate mortgages state the rate compounded semi-annually, as the Interest Act requires, so the payment is about $16 a month lower than with monthly compounding. This version uses half-yearly compounding by default; switch Rate compounding to Monthly for most variable-rate products.

Land transfer tax is the biggest up-front cost. Ontario charges 0.5% up to $55,000, 1% to $250,000, 1.5% to $400,000 and 2% above that (2.5% over $2 million for a house), which is $13,475 on $850,000. Inside Toronto the municipal land transfer tax is charged again on the same brackets, so the buyer pays $26,950 before legal fees. First-time buyers can claim an Ontario refund of up to $4,000 and a Toronto rebate of up to $4,475.

With $2,800 a month in rent rising 3%, condo fees of $700 a month and 3% price growth, the renter who invests the $199,450 the buyer spends up front is still ahead by about $50,700 after 10 years at a 5% return. Change the price-to-rent ratio, the growth rate or the return and the answer moves quickly, which is the point of running it.

  • Net worth comparison with opportunity cost of the down payment and closing costs
  • Selling costs, maintenance, property tax, insurance and HOA
  • Mortgage interest and property tax deduction at your marginal rate
  • Break-even year, cumulative cost and net worth charts
  • Shareable link with every input
Read the guide: Rent vs Buy: Comparing Net Worth, Not Monthly Payments

Updated

How to use the Rent vs Buy Calculator

  1. Enter the price, your down payment, the contract rate and the amortization. Keep Rate compounding on half-yearly for a fixed-rate mortgage.
  2. In Closing Costs, add land transfer tax (provincial, plus municipal in Toronto), legal fees, title insurance and the home inspection.
  3. Under 20% down, add the CMHC premium to the loan by lowering the down payment by the premium, and add the provincial sales tax on it to Closing Costs (see the second example).
  4. Enter property tax, insurance, maintenance and condo fees for the owner and tenant insurance for the renter. Leave the tax rate at 0, since interest on your own home is not deductible.
  5. Set selling costs to the realtor commission and legal fees you expect, then read the break-even year.

Worked examples

Toronto condo, 20% down

Input

$850,000, $170,000 down, 4.5% fixed compounded semi-annually over 25 years, $29,450 closing costs ($26,950 provincial and municipal land transfer tax, $2,500 legal), condo fees $8,400 a year, property tax $5,500, 5% selling costs, rent $2,800 rising 3%, 3% growth, 5% return, 10 years

Output

Mortgage $3,763.62 a month; renting ahead by $70,950 after year 1 and by $50,730 after 10 years

With monthly compounding the same loan would cost $3,779.66 a month and renting would lead by $53,939. The gap between buying and renting narrows every year, but at these assumptions the buyer needs more than 10 years to catch up.

Same condo with 10% down and CMHC insurance

Input

$85,000 down; CMHC premium 3.10% of the $765,000 loan ($23,715) added to the mortgage, entered as a $61,285 down payment; closing costs $31,347 including 8% Ontario sales tax on the premium ($1,897)

Output

Mortgage $4,365.32 a month; renting ahead by $48,698 after 10 years

The premium is financed, so it raises the loan rather than the cash spent; only the sales tax on it must be paid at closing. Less cash up front means the renter has less to invest, which is why the gap is a little smaller even though the payment is higher.

Background and insight

The fair comparison is net worth, not monthly payments. The approach follows the structure popularised by the New York Times rent-versus-buy calculator: the renter starts with the down payment and closing costs invested, and every year whichever household spends less invests the difference at the investment return. The buyer ends with the home's value after selling costs, minus the remaining loan, plus anything they invested. Leaving out that opportunity cost makes buying look better than it is.

With the defaults (400,000 home, 80,000 down, 8,000 closing, 6.5% for 30 years, 2,500 rent), the monthly principal and interest is 2,022.62. In year one the buyer is 22,128 behind, mostly because 6% selling costs and 8,000 of closing costs vanish on day one. The buyer moves ahead in year 3 and leads by about 113,700 after 10 years at 3% appreciation and 7% investment return. Set selling costs to 0 and buying wins from year 1, which shows how much transaction costs matter if you might move soon.

The tax line assumes you itemise and can deduct all mortgage interest and property tax. In the US many households take the standard deduction instead, and state and local tax deductions are capped, so for them the real benefit is smaller or zero. Set Marginal Tax Rate to 0 to see the result without it.

Common use cases

  • Deciding whether to buy now

    Find the break-even year and compare it with how long you expect to stay.

  • Testing a rate change

    Change the Interest Rate to see how much a point on the mortgage moves the payment and the outcome.

  • Comparing a specific listing and rental

    Enter real tax, HOA and rent figures for two homes you are choosing between.

  • Checking an agent's claim

    Test "rent is dead money" by adding the opportunity cost of the down payment.

Tips and limitations

  • You qualify at the higher of 5.25% and your contract rate plus 2 points (the stress test), so check affordability at that rate before relying on the result.
  • Most fixed terms are five years on a 25-year amortization; rerun the calculator at the rate you expect at renewal.
  • Minimum down payment is 5% of the first $500,000 and 10% of the rest, and homes of $1.5 million or more need 20%.
  • A First Home Savings Account or TFSA lets the renter invest without tax on the growth, which matches the tool's untaxed return.
  • Newer rental units may sit outside provincial rent control, so pick a rent increase that fits the unit, not the guideline.

Sources and further reading

  1. Interest Act, section 6, Justice Laws Website, Government of Canada. Mortgage rates stated "calculated yearly or half-yearly, not in advance".
  2. Calculating land transfer tax, Government of Ontario
  3. Municipal Land Transfer Tax rates and fees, City of Toronto
  4. Municipal Land Transfer Tax rebate opportunities, City of Toronto. First-time purchaser rebate of up to $4,475.
  5. Mortgage loan insurance cost, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. Premiums by loan-to-value and provincial sales tax on premiums.
  6. Income tax information you need to know if you bought or sold a home, Canada Revenue Agency. Principal residence exemption and reporting the sale.
  7. Saving for a down payment, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada. Minimum down payment by purchase price.
  8. Preparing to get a mortgage (stress test), Financial Consumer Agency of Canada

Frequently asked questions

Why is my Canadian mortgage payment lower than a US calculator shows?

Because a Canadian fixed rate is compounded semi-annually, not monthly. A 4.5% rate is equivalent to about 4.458% compounded monthly, so on a $680,000 loan over 25 years the payment is $3,763.62 instead of $3,779.66. Variable-rate mortgages are often compounded monthly; check your mortgage contract.

How much land transfer tax will I pay in Toronto?

On $850,000, Ontario land transfer tax is $13,475 and the Toronto municipal tax is the same again, $26,950 in total. First-time buyers can get up to $4,000 back from Ontario and up to $4,475 from the city. Outside Toronto only the provincial tax applies, and other provinces have their own transfer taxes or registration fees.

How do I include CMHC mortgage insurance?

Below 20% down the loan must be insured. CMHC's premium is 3.10% of the loan at 85.01% to 90% loan-to-value and 4.00% at 90.01% to 95%. It is usually added to the mortgage, so lower the down payment by the premium; in Ontario, Quebec and Saskatchewan the provincial sales tax on it is paid in cash at closing.

Can I deduct mortgage interest in Canada?

Not on the home you live in, which is why this version sets the tax rate to 0. Interest can be deductible when the borrowed money earns rental or business income, but that is a different calculation.

Will I pay capital gains tax when I sell my home?

Generally not, if it was your principal residence for every year you owned it. You still report the sale and designate the property on Schedule 3 of your return. The calculator does not tax the sale for that reason.

Do condo fees belong in the comparison?

Yes. They pay for building insurance, common areas and the reserve fund, and the renter does not pay them directly. That is why maintenance is lower in the Toronto example: much of it is inside the $700 monthly fee.

Is there an in-depth guide to the Rent vs Buy Calculator?

Yes. “Rent vs Buy: Comparing Net Worth, Not Monthly Payments” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.