Idea Prioritizer

Rank startup ideas with a weighted decision matrix: rate impact, effort, confidence, market size and founder fit from 1 to 10 and set your own weights.

The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.

About this tool

What is the Idea Prioritizer?

The Idea Prioritizer ranks competing startup ideas with a weighted scoring matrix. Each idea gets five sliders from 1 to 10: Impact, Effort (lower is better), Confidence, Market Size and Founder Market Fit. You set how much each criterion matters with weight sliders in 5% steps, and the ideas re-rank instantly with a score out of 10.

The score is the weighted average of the five ratings, with effort flipped so that an effort of 1 counts as 10 and an effort of 10 counts as 1. An idea rated perfectly on everything scores exactly 10; the weakest possible idea scores 1. The ranking badge is green at 7 or above, amber from 5 and red below 5.

Ideas are saved in your browser (key idea-prioritizer) and weights separately (idea-prioritizer-criteria). Export downloads a text report with the weights, every idea's ratings and the top three. Load Sample Ideas adds four example ideas with balanced 20% weights.

  • Five criteria rated 1 to 10 for every idea
  • Adjustable weights with a 100% budget
  • Live ranking with a score out of 10
  • Text export of weights, ratings and top three
  • Saved in your browser, four-idea sample
Read the guide: Choosing a Startup Idea: The Idea Maze, Scoring Matrices and Pivots

Updated

How to use the Idea Prioritizer

  1. Set the five Scoring Criteria Weights so the total shows 100%.
  2. Type an idea name under Add New Idea and click Add (or press Enter). Add every idea you are weighing.
  3. Rate each idea on the five sliders. For Effort, a low number means easy.
  4. Read the Ideas Ranking: ideas re-sort by score as you move any slider.
  5. Click Export to download idea-prioritization-analysis.txt with weights, ratings and the top three.

Worked example

Scoring the sample ideas with 20% weights

Input

Mental Health Support Chatbot: impact 8, effort 5, confidence 7, market 8, founder fit 9
Remote Team Collaboration VR Tool: impact 9, effort 9, confidence 5, market 6, founder fit 7

Output

Chatbot 7.60, VR Tool 5.80

Effort is inverted as 11 - effort, so 5 becomes 6 and 9 becomes 2. The chatbot scores (8 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9) / 5 = 7.6; the VR tool scores (9 + 2 + 5 + 6 + 7) / 5 = 5.8. The VR tool's high impact cannot offset its effort and low confidence. The other two samples score 7.00 (food delivery) and 6.80 (finance assistant).

Background and insight

This is a weighted decision matrix, sometimes called a Pugh matrix after Stuart Pugh, who used a similar method for engineering concept selection. It is not RICE or ICE, although it is related. RICE, from Intercom, scores Reach x Impact x Confidence / Effort, and ICE, associated with Sean Ellis, multiplies Impact, Confidence and Ease. Both multiply, so one very low factor drags the whole score down. A weighted average adds, so a strong market can compensate for a weaker founder fit. That makes the matrix better at comparing whole startup ideas and RICE better at ranking features for an existing product with known reach.

The weights are where the real decision happens. A solo technical founder might put 30% on founder market fit; a team with funding but no distribution might weight market size and confidence. Weights should add up to 100%. The sliders stop you going over, and a warning appears when the total is under 100%; the score is normalised by the total weight, so it stays on the same 1 to 10 scale either way.

Ratings are guesses, and the matrix is only as good as the evidence behind them. A useful habit is to write down why each idea got its confidence score and to re-score after a week of customer interviews. If the ranking flips with a small weight change, the ideas are effectively tied and you should test both cheaply rather than trust the decimal places.

Common use cases

  • Choosing between startup ideas

    Put three to six ideas side by side with weights that reflect your team's real constraints.

  • Choosing a side project

    Weight founder fit and effort heavily to pick something you will actually finish.

  • Team or co-founder discussions

    Have each person set weights separately and compare rankings to see where priorities differ.

  • Revisiting a decision

    Re-score after customer interviews and see whether the leader changes.

Tips and limitations

  • Weights total 100% by design. Raising one slider stops at the remaining budget, so lower another first.
  • Treat differences under about 0.5 as ties and test both ideas cheaply.
  • Effort is inverted: an effort rating of 2 helps the score far more than 8 does.
  • Load Sample Ideas only works on an empty list; delete existing ideas with the bin icon first.
  • Write evidence for Confidence ratings somewhere. Without it, confidence is just enthusiasm.

Sources and further reading

  1. RICE Prioritization Framework for Product Managers, Intercom. The Reach, Impact, Confidence and Effort score the page compares with a weighted matrix
  2. Decision-matrix method, Wikipedia. The Pugh concept-selection matrix the weighted scoring is based on

Frequently asked questions

How is the idea priority score calculated?

The score is the weighted average of the five ratings: impact, inverted effort (11 minus effort), confidence, market size and founder market fit, each multiplied by its weight and divided by the total weight. It runs from 1 to 10.

What is the difference between RICE and a weighted scoring matrix?

RICE multiplies Reach, Impact and Confidence and divides by Effort, so a single weak factor sinks the score. A weighted matrix averages several criteria with weights you choose. RICE suits feature backlogs with measurable reach; a weighted matrix suits comparing whole ideas.

What is ICE scoring?

ICE scoring rates Impact, Confidence and Ease, usually from 1 to 10, and multiplies them (some teams average them instead). It is associated with growth marketer Sean Ellis and is popular for ranking growth experiments because it is quick.

Why is effort inverted in the idea score?

Because less effort is better. Effort is converted with 11 minus the rating, so an effort of 1 counts as 10 and an effort of 10 counts as 1, putting it on the same scale as the other criteria where higher is better.

What weights should I use to rank startup ideas?

Start with 20% each, then move weight toward your real constraint. Limited runway favours effort and confidence; an experienced domain founder can weight founder market fit; a venture-backed plan leans toward market size. Check whether the leader changes when you shift 10 points.

Can the weights add up to less than 100%?

Yes, temporarily. A warning shows until they total 100%. Scores are normalised by the total weight, so they stay on the same 1 to 10 scale while you adjust, but set the weights to 100% before exporting.

Is there an in-depth guide to the Idea Prioritizer?

Yes. “Choosing a Startup Idea: The Idea Maze, Scoring Matrices and Pivots” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.