Job Offer Evaluation Checklist
Pension contribution can outweigh the pay difference, notice periods and non-competes bind you, and a verbal offer is not a job. Compare the whole package.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Job Offer Evaluation Checklist?
Offers are compared on salary and lost on everything else: an employer pension contribution worth more than the pay difference, a notice period that traps you, a non-compete nobody read, and a verbal offer that changed after a resignation.
One rule has no exception. Get the full offer in writing before accepting or resigning, with every condition cleared, because an offer subject to references or checks is not yet a job.
- Compares total package, including the pension contribution people ignore
- Converts hours and commute into money
- Covers the clauses that bind you after acceptance
- Insists on a written offer with conditions cleared before resigning
- Editable and exportable as PDF, CSV, Markdown or a Google Form
Updated
How to use the Job Offer Evaluation Checklist
- Add up everything with monetary value, especially employer pension contribution, bonus terms, equity and leave.
- Convert hours and commute into money, and compare like for like rather than headline salary.
- Read the clauses that bind you: notice, non-compete, intellectual property, probation and repayment terms.
- Ask why the role is vacant, how success is measured, and to speak to a prospective peer.
- Get the full offer in writing with conditions cleared before accepting or resigning, and negotiate once.
Worked examples
Two offers to compare
Input
Whole package section
Output
Pension, bonus, equity, leave and commute all costed
Identical salaries can differ substantially.
Before signing
Input
Clauses section
Output
Notice, non-compete, IP and repayment clauses read
These bind you after you accept.
Offer by phone
Input
Accepting section
Output
Written offer obtained and conditions cleared before resigning
A conditional offer is not yet a job.
Background and insight
Total package comparison is the first section because it changes conclusions. Employer pension contribution, bonus terms, equity, health cover, leave and allowances can make two identical salaries meaningfully different, and a few percentage points of pension contribution compounds into a very large sum over a career. Leave is a real pay difference too, which is why whether public holidays sit inside or outside the stated number matters.
Hours and commute convert into money as well. A higher salary for ten more hours a week and an extra hour of travelling is frequently a pay cut once the arithmetic is done.
The clauses section covers what binds you after you accept. A long notice period limits your next move while a short one limits your security. Non-compete, non-solicit and garden leave clauses vary in enforceability by jurisdiction and are not harmless. Intellectual property clauses matter to anyone who makes things outside work, some claiming anything created during employment. And repayment clauses on bonuses, training or relocation can mean owing money you have already spent if you leave within a period.
A stated place of work matters more than it looks: a remote arrangement that is a manager's preference rather than a contract term can be withdrawn.
On the job itself, three questions produce the most information: why the role is vacant and what happened to the last person, how success is measured and what the first ninety days look like, and whether you can speak to a prospective peer rather than only the manager. Weighing the manager heavily is rational, since who you report to affects daily experience more than the company name and is the most common reason people leave.
Finally, accepting. Asking for a few days is normal and pressure to decide immediately is information about how the organisation operates. Negotiate once, properly, with a researched number and the non-salary items in the same conversation. And declining warmly matters, because you may apply there again or be interviewed by that person somewhere else.
Common use cases
Comparing offers
Total package arithmetic rather than headline salary.
A first offer
What the clauses mean and what to ask before accepting.
Changing employer
Notice, non-competes and repayment clauses that affect the move.
Declining well
Doing it promptly and warmly, because you may meet them again.
Tips and limitations
- Check whether public holidays are inside or outside the stated leave number.
- Ask what happened to the last person in the role. The answer is always informative.
- Weigh the manager heavily; it affects daily life more than the company name.
- Ask to speak to a prospective peer. A refusal is itself an answer.
- Never resign on a verbal offer, and make sure every condition is cleared first.
Sources and further reading
- Employment contracts, UK Government. Terms, notice periods and written statements
- Pay and wages, Acas. Pay, deductions and contractual entitlements
- Occupational Outlook Handbook, US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Typical pay and outlook by occupation for comparison
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare two job offers?
Add up everything with monetary value: base pay, bonus terms, equity, employer pension contribution, health cover, leave and allowances, then convert the hours and commute into money too. Pension contribution alone can outweigh a modest salary difference.
What should I check in an offer letter?
Salary, start date, hours, notice in both directions, probation terms, place of work, holiday, and any conditions such as references or checks. Then the clauses: non-compete, intellectual property and any repayment terms on bonuses, training or relocation.
Are non-compete clauses enforceable?
It varies by jurisdiction and by how broadly they are drafted, and they are not harmless to ignore. If a clause would restrict the work you would want to do next, raise it before accepting rather than after, and take advice if it is significant.
Should I resign before getting the offer in writing?
No, and not until every condition is cleared. An offer subject to references, background checks or right to work is not yet a job, and a verbal offer that changes after you resign leaves you with neither position.
What questions should I ask before accepting?
Why the role is vacant and what happened to the last person, how success is measured, what the first ninety days look like, what progression has actually looked like for others, and whether you can speak to someone who would be a peer.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Job Offer Evaluation Checklist?
Yes. “Why Checklists Work, and How to Use One Properly” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.